What Does Peanut Butter Taste Like? In-Depth Peanut Butter Taste Guide

Peanut butter is delicious and highly nutritious food with millions of fans around the world. Peanut butter is a great source of energy, and is often eaten for breakfast or before a work out. Peanut butter is the most popular spread in the world – did you know that according to Statista, over 612 million peanut butter units are sold in the US alone per year?

But what makes peanut butter so popular? The answer is its unique taste and texture! In this article, we will tell you what peanut butter tastes like, why it is so addictive, and what it goes well with.

What does peanut butter taste like? Peanut butter has a nutty, creamy, earthy, and salty flavor reminiscent of fried peanuts. Peanut butter has a smooth, delicate texture and is never too dry or oily. High-quality peanut butter shouldn’t taste bitter or sweet – it should have a mild, tender, nutty flavor with hints of salt and butter.

Peanut Butter Taste – All You Need to Know

Peanut butter is made of grounded roasted peanuts. It can have different textures, depending on how the peanuts are grounded – peanut butter can be smooth or crunchy. The demand for peanut butter in the US is very high, so it can be found in any grocery shop. Peanut butter is fairly affordable and, according to Walmart, comes at $2.48 per 16.3 oz (462 grams). Let’s dive into the peanut butter taste, smell, and texture to see why it became an inalienable part of the modern American diet!

What is the taste of peanut butter? Peanut butter taste is described as a “thick, rich, earthy, deep caramel-like flavor with hints of pleasant sweetness and saltiness.” Peanut butter texture is similar to thick mashed potatoes with lots of butter. Peanut butter has a bold, fresh flavor that makes you want to eat more. 

Peanut butter taste and texture depend on the ingredients – some manufacturers add sweeteners, including cocoa, sugar, honey, and other ingredients. The best peanut butter contains only roasted peanuts and sea salt. Peanut butter can also be homemade – all you need to do is to put peanuts in a food processor until you get the desired consistency (usually 4-5 minutes) and add a pinch of sea salt!

Is peanut butter sweet or salty? 100% pure peanut butter with no added sugar is salty and savory. However, most manufacturers add sugar or other sweeteners to make peanut butter tastier. Since peanuts naturally contain some sugar, peanut butter will only be slightly sweet, so pure peanut butter is more savory and salty than sweet.

Peanut butter with no added sugar still contains natural sugar (around 9 grams of sugar per 100 grams of peanut butter), so it has a slightly sweet flavor reminiscent of honey and caramel. However, unsweetened peanut butter has a much more salty flavor than sweet, so it is often eaten with jam or honey. We recommend eating a moderate amount of peanut butter to avoid consuming too many calories.

See also: 8 Best Avocado Substitutes in a Salad

Does peanut butter taste good? Peanut butter does taste good thanks to salt and fat and is the most popular spread in the US. According to Statista, Americans spend $2.4 billion on peanut butter annually. Peanut butter is loved for its unique nutty flavor and how it sticks to the roof of the mouth before melting. 

Since pure peanut butter is 99.3% peanuts, it contains a lot of oil and tastes like peanuts! Healthy fats, added salt, and the slight natural sweetness of peanuts combine two flavors – sweet and salty, which confuse your taste receptors and give that umami flavor.

Why is peanut butter so tasty? Most peanut butter fans say that peanut butter is so tasty because of the combination of salt, oil, and delicate crunch texture. Pure peanut butter sticks to the roof of your mouth and pleases your taste receptors with the luscious, rich salty, and sweet notes.

If your peanut butter tastes bitter, it either went off because of improper storage (nuts become rancid when exposed to light, moisture and heat), or it is of poor quality with added chemicals. Fresh peanut butter never tastes bitter or bad.

It is estimated that 75% of the Americans have at least 1 jar of peanut butter in their kitchen!

So, how would you describe the taste of peanut butter? Peanut butter taste is described as “thick Nutella spread without chocolate but less sweet and saltier,” “sunflower seeds turned into paste,” “thick mashed potatoes with salt and butter,” or even “mud combined with oil.” Try peanut butter today to see which description you agree with the most!

As you see, peanut butter taste descriptions vary significantly – some people compare it to Nutella, and some people say it tastes like mud and oil. There is no unanimous opinion on what peanut butter really tastes like, so you will need to try it yourself to see if you like it. What we can conclude, though, is that high-quality organic peanut butter without any sweeteners is a great source of protein and healthy fats, which will give you energy for many hours!

See also: What Does Chamoy Taste Like? Is It Sweet or Spicy?

Why is peanut butter so addictive? Peanut butter is so addictive because of the high salt and fat content, making peanut butter texture smooth, crunchy, not too oily or dry – just a perfectly balanced level of moisture. Also, salt and sweet notes create two camps of flavors satisfying your taste receptors.

Now that you know what peanut butter tastes like, let’s see what it goes with and how you can incorporate this healthy food into your diet.

What Does Peanut Butter Go With?

Peanut butter is truly versatile and can be eaten for breakfast, lunch, and dinner (avoid eating too much if you are on a diet). Since peanut butter is highly nutritious, one or two teaspoons will be enough. However, it is not uncommon not to be able to stop eating peanut butter, especially when eaten with tea or coffee. Let’s look at some of the ways you can enjoy peanut butter:

  • Eat straight from the jar
  • Spread on a toast or biscuits
  • Add to cereal or granola
  • Add to ice cream, desserts, baked goods (pies, muffins), and smoothies
  • Eat with fruits (banana, raspberry, strawberry)
  • Add to salads
  • Make fish and meat sauces

Every year, Americans consume over 300 million kg of peanut butter. Even though the most common way to eat peanut butter is to spread it on toast, there are dozens of other ways! Peanut butter goes well with crackers, biscuits, and muffins. It can also be added to oatmeal or granola instead of butter. Peanut butter is often added to fruit and vegetable salads, giving them a pleasant nutty, earthy flavor and peanut aroma. Peanut butter is used to make baked goods, including pies, muffins, biscuits, and cakes. If you have a sweet tooth, consider adding peanut butter to ice cream, a smoothie, or milkshake.

Peanut butter also goes well with non-sweet foods, for example, pasta and risotto – peanut butter gives them a distinct nutty flavor. Sometimes, peanut butter is a great oil substitute for frying. Surprisingly, peanut butter is used to make meat sauces and marinades, so if you have never tried it before, why not do it today?


With over 75% of Americans eating peanut butter regularly, it is no surprise that it is the most popular spread in the US and one of the most popular in the world. Peanut butter attracts us with its unique sweet and salty flavor and its delicate, smooth, or crunchy texture that makes the peanut butter stick to the roof of your mouth before it melts.

There are different peanut butter varieties on the market, including reduced-fat, with honey/sugar/chocolate/caramel, or whipped. However, we still think that the original peanut + salt combination works the best. Try peanut butter today, and you will quickly find yourself enjoying its nutty, earthy flavor and delicate texture!

Recent Posts